York vs Carlisle Correct Score Prediction: Team Stats, H2H & Betting Insights

Our York vs Carlisle Prediction: 1-1

York vs Carlisle in the England National League is scheduled for an 18:45 GMT kick-off on Tuesday September 23, 2025. We anticipate a balanced game ending in a 1-1 draw, and given both teams’ scoring form, BTTS looks like a safe bet.

This York vs Carlisle prediction is backed by a deep dive into both teams' recent performances, key stats and head-to-head history — all of which you'll find detailed below to help you make an informed betting decision.

→ View Today's Full-Time Score Predictions

Recent Form Insights

York's Last Match – York vs Solihull Moors

York will hope to recover from their recent 0-1 England National League setback against Solihull Moors on September 20. In that match, York had 50% possession and 3 shots on target.

Team	Possession	Shots (on target)	xG	Dangerous Attacks
York	50%	0 (3)	-	92
Solihull Moors	50%	0 (2)	-	16

Carlisle's Last Match – Altrincham vs Carlisle

Determined to maintain their recent success, Carlisle must win following their 2-1 England National League victory against Altrincham on September 20. In that match, Carlisle recorded 45% possession, firing 2 shots on target.

Team	Possession	Shots (on target)	xG	Dangerous Attacks
Altrincham	55%	0 (3)	-	77
Carlisle	45%	0 (2)	-	79

York vs Carlisle Stats

Key Stats

Goals Scored vs Goals Conceded

York are averaging 1.7 goals scored and 0.7 conceded per match, while Carlisle average 2.1 scored and 0.7 conceded per game.

What are the odds for this match?

York to win: @1.85

Draw: @3.6

Carlisle to win: @3.4

Lineups

York: Alex Hunt, Malachi Fagan-Walcott, Alex Newby, Tyrese Sinclair, Joe Grey, Mark Kitching, Hiram Boateng, Joseph Rabole Felix, Ollie Pearce, Callum Howe, Harrison Male

Carlisle: Alex Gilliead, Harvey Macadam, Jack Ellis, Sam Murray, Gabriel Breeze, Regan Linney, Bevis Mugabi, Terell Thomas, Archie Daniel Davies, Stephen Wearne, Luke Armstrong

York Fixtures

Carlisle Fixtures